Tarte is a brand that beauty experts love and trust. Their products are known for their commitment to using high-quality, natural ingredients in their products, free of artificial dyes and chemicals. Because of this, many eco-conscious shoppers flock to their products, especially when looking for mascara options. When finding a mascara to use on one of the most sensitive places on our faces – our eyes – it’s especially important to know exactly what’s in our products. Read on to learn more about Tarte mascara options to help you decide which one is the right fit for you.

At a glance, best Tarte mascaras

Mascara NameRating
Lights Camera Lashes 4-in-1 Natural Mascara
Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara
Tarteist Lash Paint Mascara
Maneater Magnetic Voluptuous Mascara
Lifted Sweatproof Mascara
Big Ego Vegan Mascara
Limited-edition Tarte Athleisure Essentials
Prime Pretties Color Collection

Top 8 Tarte Mascara

According to my new year resolution, I was committed to using mascaras regularly. And I have tried many mascaras brand. But I liked Tarte’s plant-based mascara formula very much. And these 8 are the finest Tarte mascara that is plant-based and completely chemical-free.

1. Lights Camera Lashes 4-in-1 Natural Mascara

Lights Camera Lashes 4-in-1 Natural Mascara

Up first is a lengthening, curling, volumizing, and conditioning mascara that gives lashes a “push up.” This mascara is infused with olive esters to condition, treat, and protect lashes, while also plumping them up (clinical trials have shown a 424% increase in lash volume). This mascara is comprised of plant botanicals and wax that conditions lashes while remaining free of parabens, petrochemicals, sulfates, preservatives, oil, gluten, dye, talc, and fragrance.

For many users, they’ve seen thickening and lengthening results of this mascara in just one swipe. However, this is one of the pricier Tarte mascaras out there, but many users claim it’s worth every penny. The formula stays on all day and doesn’t clump or smudge. However, this does mean you’ll need a powerful cleanser at the end of the day to completely remove it. But if you’re looking for a plumping, natural mascara for all-day wear, this may be one to consider.

  • 424% increase of lashes, clinically proven
  • After the first application noticeable lash volume growth
  • No chemical like parabens, petrochemicals, sulfates, preservatives, oil, gluten, dye, talc, and fragrance
  • 4 in 1 formula

  • Dry out quickly because of the mascara formula is dry

Check this 4 in 1 mascara in Amazon

2. Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara

Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara

The Amazonian clay is this mascara makes it the first mascara that instinctively lengthens, conditions, repairs and replenishes dry and brittle lashes. The clay is known to balance, nourish, hydrate, and repair lashes to make lashes healthier and stronger and to prevent lash loss.

This mascara might be a great choice if you have sensitive or dry eyes, as the formula is soft and nourish, doesn’t flake, and doesn’t irritate the eyes. Some users report that it’s also long-lasting and won’t budge throughout the day. The nourishing aspect of this mascara can make you feel better about putting makeup on your eyes that is also “treating” your lashes at the same time. A great option for those who might need to repair or boost lash growth.

  • Best mascara for the sensitive eye
  • Long-lasting mascara
  • Quickly repair dry and brittle lashes
  • Smart mascara that can find out what treatment your lashes need

  • Price little high
  • Make sure you get new stocks, old stocks dry out quickly

Check this Amazonian Clay Mascara in Amazon

3. Tarteist Lash Paint Mascara

Tarteist Lash Paint Mascara

This vegan option gives a painted-on dramatic look while still using good-for-you ingredients. The formula here is infused with triple-black painted mineral pigments that strengthen and condition lashes while giving a bold black color. This means great length and volume and without artificial ingredients!

Lovers of this Tarte option praise its ability to last all day without flaking. Those looking for a vegan option will appreciate the dramatic look that’s comparable to more drug-store brands. However, it doesn’t seem to be as water-resistant as other options, which can lead to some runniness issues. However, the more “liquidy” consistency of this formula means it comes off super easy with a swipe of a makeup wipe at the end of the day.

  • Great everyday mascara, it lasts a whole day without flaking
  • Color is great
  • Easy to remove with eye makeup remover
  • Comes with an excellent wand

  • Not waterproof
  • Price is higher than drugstore mascaras

Check this Tarteist Lash Paint mascara in Amazon

4. Maneater Magnetic Voluptuous Mascara

Maneater Magnetic Voluptuous Mascara

This mascara is a lengthening and volumizing mascara. It has a soft-flex brush and lightweight formula. Maneater lifts lashes at the root and fans them out to create amped-up fullness. The custom-molded brush features hundreds of tiny bristles, designed to evenly coat without making a clumpy mess. It does this by using a creamy formula with jojoba oil and carnauba wax. This mascara works best with two coats to catch every lash and create a high-volume look.

Users report that this Tarte option provides great length and volume and no clumps. The more precise brush style means every lash gets caught and can be used to create a winged or cat-eye style. Plus, with jojoba oil, lashes don’t feel stiff. However, with such high volume means that sometimes this mascara can leave dark marks around the eyes, or that the formula rubs into the eyeshadow. It has also been known to leave “dust” under the eyes or black specs. Users should try out small or trial size of this one to see if this high-volume formula is a good fit.

  • 100% organic mascara, no harmful chemicals
  • It’s a long-lasting mascara
  • Lengthens lashes without any clamp
  • Awesome brush, better than other Tarte mascaras
  • It’s not waterproof
  • Costly mascara but it worth every penny

Check Maneater Magnetic Voluptuous mascara in Amazon

5. Lifted Sweatproof Mascara

Lifted Sweatproof Mascara

This option is a vegan and sweatproof mascara that still lifts and volumizes while you sweat or swim. It boasts that users won’t have a “raccoon eye” effect, even after the toughest workout. This waterproof formula is reinforced with Amazonian clay, vitamin C, and emollient wax to naturally soften and promote healthy lashes with all-natural ingredients.

Most claim that this waterproof version works very well, holding up all day and night without a re-apply. It is a definite pick for those needing something that they can apply once and leave all day through sweating, workouts, or nights out on the town. However, some did report a bit of flakiness with this formula, and the shade of this tube is not the “deepest” black option that is out there – it has a more natural look. If that’s what you’re looking for, the Lifted sweatproof formula might work well for you.

  • Sweatproof and waterproof
  • 100% natural ingredients, improved formula
  • Best 24-hour mascara even if you are doing a heavy workout or swimming
  • Prevent lash loss

  • Highly-priced mascara because of the great sweatproof and waterproof formula

Check Lifted Sweatproof mascara in Amazon

6. Big Ego Vegan Mascara

Big Ego Vegan Mascara

This is another vegan, lash-loving formula that is plant-powered by babassu to nurture and condition lashes. It’s ultra-black and can deliver coverage for up to 16 hours. Babassu is used to nourish, while the glycerin hydrates and vitamin B5 provides antioxidants. The brush design mimics the curve of your lashes so volume is built root to tip. It features a twisted, double-fiber-bristle brush to deliver maximum pigment.

This mascara is a good choice for those looking for a vegan option that is great for layering in multiple coats without flaking. This choice might also inspire some as this mascara is serving as a launchpad for a new Tarte self-love campaign, as the name “Big Ego” suggests.

  • Ultra black vegan mascara
  • With Babassu, Glycerin, and Panthenol (vitamin B5) helps
  • Twisted double fiber brush
  • 100% plant-powered formula
  • Like other Tarte mascara, it dries out quickly too
  • Double fiber brush sometimes difficult to apply

Check Big Ego Vegan mascara in Amazon

7. Limited-edition Tarte Athleisure Essentials

Limited-edition Tarte Athleisure Essentials

This collection includes four gym bag-friendly, vegan options for a hydrated and radiant look. This one includes a version of the Lifted Sweatproof mascara, with a black-brown shade for a more natural lash look. This bundle is a great option if your lifestyle moves you from the gym to the office with little time for a touch-up. In addition to the Lifted mascara, you’ll find a moisturizer, lip shade, and makeup wipes. This bundle might be a good idea due to the wipes and mascara combo, which let you easily remove and reapply as needed.

While users might not find their everyday staples in this kit, it is a great option for something to leave in your gym bag for a reliable look on the go. It offers a high-value bundle with other Tarte products that were formulated for a gym to work look. Some users of the bundle aren’t impressed with the minimal lift or color of the bundle’s mascara, but for those preferring a natural, no-smudge look, this might be an ideal pick.

Check this Athleisure Essentials in Amazon

8. Prime Pretties Color Collection

Prime Pretties Color Collection

This second collection option offers three vegan products for those who want to keep this consistent in their makeup. The set includes a travel-size mascara, lip paint, and eyeliner for a dramatic look on the go that still doesn’t use artificial ingredients. The mascara in this bundle is a smaller version of the Tartiest lash paint, which is a high-volume choice that is still made with vegan options. The best yet is that these dramatics are still vegan dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested as safe for contact lens wearers.

Lovers of this bundle enjoy the rich, ultra-black pigment of the mascara that still nourishes and softens. The natural waxes inside help lengthen the appearance of lashes while leaving them soft. It also gives a nice “separating” look that can give a bold appearance from a small tube. This bundle is a great option for keeping a dramatic look together that is still completely vegan and natural.

Check Prime Pretties Color Collection in Amazon

Tarte’s Commitment to Excellence

Since being founded by Maureen Kelly in 2000, Tarte has been making all-natural makeup with high-quality, nourishing ingredients. Kelly founded the company because she herself could not find effective makeup on the market that worked for her – she wanted a glam look while still being all-natural in her products. She studied and researched products to use, such as Amazonian clay, goji berry extract, passionfruit, and vitamins A, C, and E. 

She has continued in her commitment to using natural products and as the company has grown over the years, it continues to avoid using parabens, synthetic fragrances, or gluten in their products. Tarte is also a cruelty-free brand, meaning it doesn’t test on animals or sell products in places where animal testing is legal.

Additionally, many products in the Tarte line are vegan as well. Tarte is open and honest about their ingredients, which can be found at the bottom of every Tarte product page on their website. The company believes in providing every user with a full list of ingredients for every shade so that users can decide whether the product aligns with their personal beliefs and lifestyle choices.

Final words

Depending on what you value most in your mascara, you can find a variety of products in Tarte’s lineup. Their cruelty-free brand and commitment to using all-natural ingredients can make users feel good, knowing what exactly is going on their lashes. Plus, Tarte’s products deliver, if not exceed, the same expectations in volume and quality that many other common brands boast. If you’re looking for a new mascara, Tarte’s many options have something for everyone. This guide can help you find the best one for you before committing to purchase.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here